The pencils are the same; the theme is the decision
The Fawn & Sun 12 Double Sided Color Pencils and the Mushroom 12 Double Sided Color Pencils are the same product in different clothing. Both packs contain 12 artist-quality double-sided pencils, which means 24 colors in total, split between fluorescent and metallic shades. Both are pre-sharpened, both have shiny patterned silver foil on the barrels, and both conform to ASTM D-4236 safety testing.
That makes this a straightforward comparison. You are not choosing between two drawing experiences. You are choosing between two illustrated boxes, two artist credits, and two prices. Everything else in the supplied catalog is identical.
Side by side: what actually differs
The table below reflects only the supplied product records. Where a detail is not listed, it is marked as not confirmed rather than assumed.
- Artwork and artist: Fawn & Sun: vibrant artwork by illustrator Sarah Walsh. Mushroom: vintage artwork reimagined by collage artist Fumiha Tanaka.
- Catalog price: Fawn & Sun is listed at USD 9.61 (comparison price USD 12.99). Mushroom is listed at USD 7.92 (comparison price USD 12.99).
- Matching sketchbook: Fawn & Sun pairs with the Capybara & Sun Sketchbook. Mushroom pairs with the Mushroom Sketchbook.
- Pencil and box dimensions: Both list pencils at 0.25" x 7" and boxes at 3.5" x 8" x 0.375".
- Color range and finish: Both list 24 fade-resistant colors across fluorescent and metallic sides, with a strong, smooth line.
- Age range: Not stated in the supplied records for either set. Check the packaging before buying for a specific child.
Fawn & Sun: the brighter, slightly pricier box
- Fawn & Sun 12 Double Sided Color Pencils: 12 artist-quality, double-sided colored pencils with vibrant fluorescent and metallic colors on each side. Confirms the 24-color count and the two-tone format that defines this comparison.

Fawn & Sun 12 Double Sided Color Pencils - Fawn & Sun 12 Double Sided Color Pencils: Packaged in an intricately die-cut box with vibrant artwork by illustrator Sarah Walsh. The Sarah Walsh credit is the main differentiator if you or the recipient follow illustrators.
- Fawn & Sun 12 Double Sided Color Pencils: Pairs perfectly with matching Capybara & Sun Sketchbook. Useful if you want a coordinated gift set rather than pencils alone.
Mushroom: the lower-priced box with vintage collage art
- Mushroom 12 Double Sided Color Pencils: Packaged in an intricately die-cut box with vintage artwork reimagined by collage artist Fumiha Tanaka. The collage style gives this set a distinctly different look from Fawn & Sun's vibrant illustration.

Mushroom 12 Double Sided Color Pencils - Mushroom 12 Double Sided Color Pencils: Pairs perfectly with matching Mushroom Sketchbook. The matching sketchbook option is the same concept as Fawn & Sun, just a different theme.
- Mushroom 12 Double Sided Color Pencils: 12 double-sided, colored pencils, pre-sharpened for use right out of the box. Confirms the same ready-to-use format as Fawn & Sun, so no sharpener is needed before the first drawing.
How to choose when the cores are identical
Start with the sketchbook, not the pencils. If you already own or plan to buy the Capybara & Sun Sketchbook, the Fawn & Sun set keeps the gift visually consistent. If the Mushroom Sketchbook is the one you want, the Mushroom pencils match it. Buying the wrong pairing is the only real mismatch here.
If there is no sketchbook in the plan, let the artwork decide. The Fawn & Sun box uses vibrant illustration by Sarah Walsh; the Mushroom box uses vintage collage work by Fumiha Tanaka. Those are genuinely different aesthetics, and for a gift or keepsake, the box is part of the product.
Price is the third lever. At catalog prices, Mushroom is listed lower than Fawn & Sun, though both share the same USD 12.99 comparison price. If the two themes are equally appealing, the lower-priced set leaves more budget for paper or a sketchbook.
What the supplied records do not settle
These gaps matter if you are buying for a specific child or classroom.
- Age recommendation: Neither record states an age range. The sets conform to ASTM D-4236 safety testing, but that is not the same as an age grading.
- Care and sharpening instructions: No care or sharpening guidance is included in the supplied evidence, so follow the packaging or a general pencil sharpener appropriate to the barrel size.
- Exact color list: The records describe fluorescent and metallic colors but do not name each of the 24 shades.



